Appearance - 5.0

Nice off white creamy looking head.

Aroma - 3.0

sweetish sourish smell, still a bit of bitter to it though.

Mouthfeel - 4.0

Thick full mouth feel. Light carbonation felt.

Taste - 4.0

Slightly bitter, slightly sweet. I say it'd be close to the big name Guinness has made for itself.

Overall - 5.0

Love it, I need to get a guinness along side it for a taste test to be sure. It might be just so slightly sweeter then guinness and just slightly less bitter.